meta data for this page
Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
Both sides previous revisionPrevious revisionNext revision | Previous revision | ||
general:planned_improvements:start [2021/04/26 09:41] – [Table] Completeness 2C3 added comment gniffke | general:planned_improvements:start [2021/12/15 20:00] (current) – external edit 127.0.0.1 | ||
---|---|---|---|
Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
* 2.A.6: revised AD of some products resulting to lower emissions | * 2.A.6: revised AD of some products resulting to lower emissions | ||
* 5.D.2: NMVOC emissions from industrial wastewater handling are reported first time. | * 5.D.2: NMVOC emissions from industrial wastewater handling are reported first time. | ||
+ | * 1.A.4: Revision of PAH emission factors | ||
===== Improvements planned for future submissions ===== | ===== Improvements planned for future submissions ===== | ||
- | |||
Possible improvement issues that have been identified so far and will be checked in the future are given below: | Possible improvement issues that have been identified so far and will be checked in the future are given below: | ||
- | === Over-all inventory / all source categories=== | + | ==== Over-all inventory / all source categories==== |
* To prioritise improvements on the basis of the results of the uncertainty analysis, it is planned to determine uncertainty analysis at source category level. | * To prioritise improvements on the basis of the results of the uncertainty analysis, it is planned to determine uncertainty analysis at source category level. | ||
- | === Individual source categories=== | + | ==== Individual source categories==== |
__**stationary fuel combustion: | __**stationary fuel combustion: | ||
* measurements of POPs and heavy metal in large combustion plants (1.A.1.a) | * measurements of POPs and heavy metal in large combustion plants (1.A.1.a) | ||
* revision of SO< | * revision of SO< | ||
- | * revision of PAH Emission factors for small combustion plants | + | * further |
__**mobile fuel combustion: | __**mobile fuel combustion: | ||
Line 37: | Line 37: | ||
===== Investigated Review Findings ===== | ===== Investigated Review Findings ===== | ||
- | + | ==== NECD 2020 ==== | |
- | === NECD 2019 === | + | ^ Aspect |
+ | | General | ||
+ | | QA/QC | ||
+ | | QA/QC | ||
+ | ^ Aspect | ||
+ | | Transparency | ||
+ | | Transparency | ||
+ | | Transparency | ||
+ | ^ Aspect | ||
+ | | Consistency | ||
+ | | Consistency | ||
+ | ^ Aspect | ||
+ | | Completeness | ||
+ | | Completeness | ||
+ | | Completeness | ||
+ | | Completeness | ||
+ | | Completeness | ||
+ | | Completeness | ||
+ | | Completeness | ||
+ | ^ Aspect | ||
+ | | Accuracy | ||
+ | | Accuracy | ||
+ | ==== NECD 2019 ==== | ||
< | < | ||
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR ^ | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Transparency | 1A1 | Presents its NH< | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR ^ | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Consistency | 1A4bii | Significant fluctuations in fuel consumption over the time series | | | | | DE-1A4bii-2019-0001 | No | | | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | 1A4cii | IEF Cd trend since 2007 erratic | | | | DE-1A4cii-2018-0001 | DE-1A4cii-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | All issues regarding the inconsistency of activity data from the National Energy Balance (NEB) can only be resolved as soon as the ongoing internal revision process launched by the provider of the NEB has been finished. | | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | 1A4ciii | Large increase in AD from 2015 to 2016 | | | | DE-1A4ciii-2018-0001 | DE-1A4ciii-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | All issues regarding the inconsistency of activity data from the National Energy Balance (NEB) can only be resolved as soon as the ongoing internal revision process launched by the provider of the NEB has been finished. | | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR ^ | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Comparability | 1A4ai | Implied EFs PAHs and PCDD/F are outliers compared to other member states | | | | | DE-1A4ai-2019-0001 | No | An improvement of PAH Emission factors is planned. Currently a measurement Project is running. | | + | ^ Comparability |
- | ^ Completeness | 1A2a | NE reported for Cadmium although a default EF is available | | | | | DE-1A2a-2019-0001 | Yes | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 1A2b | NE reported for some pollutants although default EFs are available | | | | | DE-1A2b-2019-0002 | Yes | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 1A2b | NA is reported for HCB 1990 | | | | | DE-1A2b-2019-0001 | No | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 1A3b | PCB emissions missing for all years although default emission factors are available | | | | | DE-1A3b-2019-0001 | Yes | emissions calculated based on default EF | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 1A3c | Update notation key from NE to NA | | | | | DE-1A3c-2019-0001 | Yes | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2B3 | Include the NO< | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2B6 | Include the NO< | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2C1 | Potential under-estimate of emissions of HCB | | | | DE-2C1-2018-0001 | DE-2C1-2018-0001 (ID reused) | Yes | The standard emission factor is used as long as a country specific emission factor is available resulting | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2D3a | Emissions of Hg not estimated | | | | | DE-2D3a-2019-0001 | No | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2D3g | Report PAHs from 2.D.3.g Chemical Products | | | | DE-2D3g-2018-0001 | DE-2D3g-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | A project is planned to collect AD and EF for this emission source with the goal to calculate PAHs emissions. Results will be available in 2021 at the earliest, so emission reporting could not be done before submission 2022. | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 5A | Include NMVOC and PM< | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 5C2 | Emission are not estimated for PCDD/F, Pb and Cd although default EFs are available | | | | | DE-5C2-2019-0001 | Yes | Default-EF used, emissions reported. | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 5D2 | NMVOC emissions missing although default EFs exist | | | | | DE-5D2-2019-0001 | No | Ongoing process | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR ^ | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Accuracy | 1A1a | Include the revised estimate of activity data and emissions for biogas in its next submission. | | | DE-1A1a-2017-0003 | DE-1A1a-2018-0001 | DE-1A1a-2017-0003 (ID reused) | Yes | Implemented in 2020 submission | | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | 2D3a | Rationale for not estimating emissions in category 2D3a and notation key selection | | | | DE-2D3a-2018-0001 | DE-2D3a-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | Germany is in the process of evaluating data to calculate emissions of Hg from the use of fluorescent tubes. | | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | 3B | Tier 1 method used for key category | | | | | DE-3B-2019-0001 | Yes | Implemented in 2020 reporting | | + | ^ Accuracy |
</ | </ | ||
- | === NECD 2018 === | + | ==== NECD 2018 ==== |
< | < | ||
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR | | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Transparency | 1A1 | Presents its NH3 EF for stationary combustion in the next submission of its IIR, justify the use of these and compare these against the values in 2016 EMEP/EEA Guidebook. | | | DE-1A1-2017-0001 | DE-1A1-2018-0001 | DE-1A1-2017-0001 (ID reused) | No | A comparison with default values is not possible | | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | 1A1b | Include the country specific EFs for combustion in refineries in the relating chapter of its IIR to improve transparency. | | § 55 | DE-1A1b-2017-0001 | DE-1A1b-2018-0001 | | No | Emission factors are under revision. New emission factors will be included in the IIR following completion of the running refinery project. | | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | 1A3bi | Incorrect notation keys for activity data | | | | DE-1A3bi-2018-0002 | | Yes | notation keys replaced by activity data values | | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | 1A3bv | Incorrect notation keys for HCB and PCB emissions | | | | DE-1A3bv-2018-0001 | | Yes | ' | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | 2D3d | Include explanation on recalculation to 1994 in the next submission. | | | DE-2D3d-2017-0001 | DE-2D3d-2018-0001 | | No | Will be reported | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR | | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Consistency | 1A4cii | IEF Cd trend since 2007 erratic | | | | DE-1A4cii-2018-0001 | DE-1A4cii-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | All issues regarding the inconsistency of activity data from the National Energy Balance (NEB) can only be resolved as soon as the ongoing internal revision process launched by the provider of the NEB has been finished. | | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | 1A4cii | Inconsistent AD values NFR vs. IIR | | | | DE-1A4cii-2018-0001 | | Yes | no more inconsistency between NFR and IIR | | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | 1A4ciii | Large increase in AD from 2015 to 2016 | | | | DE-1A4ciii-2018-0001 | DE-1A4ciii-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | All issues regarding the inconsistency of activity data from the National Energy Balance (NEB) can only be resolved as soon as the ongoing internal revision process launched by the provider of the NEB has been finished. | | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR | | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Comparability | 5C | Hg EF is 100 times smaller than the default value proposed in the 2016 EMEP/EEA Guidebook and the Cd and Pb EF are 1000 times smaller than the default values proposed in the 2016 EMEP/EEA Guidebook | | | | DE-5-2018-0001 | | Yes | References to research Projects of CS-EF added | | + | ^ Comparability |
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR | | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Completeness | 1B2aiv | Potential under-estimate of emissions of Hg, Cd, PCDD/F | | | | DE-1B2aiv-2018-0001 | | No | Metal and PCDD/F emissions are not considered as fugitive. If IE would be used nevertheless one can assume there are such fugitives. Germany suggest to keep the notation key NA. | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2B3 | Include the NOx emissions in the next submission preferably using a country specific method to account for the specific technologies and abatement equipment applied. | | | DE-2B3-2017-0001 | DE-2B3-2018-0001 | DE-2B3-2017-0001 (ID reused) | Yes | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2B6 | Include the NOx emissions in the next submission. | | | DE-2B6-2017-0001 | DE-2B6-2018-0001 | DE-2B6-2017-0001 (ID reused) | No | Germany will look into possible implementations for this in the future. Not reported 2018. | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2C1 | Potential under-estimate of emissions of HCB | | | | DE-2C1-2018-0001 | DE-2C1-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | please see table for NECD 2019 (with the same ID) | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2C3 | Include NOx from aluminium production in the next submission to improve completeness and comparability. | | | DE-2C3-2017-0001 | DE-2C3-2018-0002 | | Yes | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2C3 | Potential under-estimate of emissions of HCB | | | | DE-2C3-2018-0001 | | Yes | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 2D3g | Report PAHs from 2D3g Chemical Products | | | | DE-2D3g-2018-0001 | DE-2D3g-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | see table for NECD 2019 (with the same ID) | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 5A | Include NMVOC and PM2.5 emissions from 5A in its next submission. | | | DE-5A-2017-0001 | DE-5A-2018-0001 | DE-5A-2017-0001 (ID reused) | Yes | Implemented in 2020 reporting. | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | 5D | Include the estimation of NMVOC emissions from wastewater treatment plant in its next submission. | | | DE-5D-2017-0001 | DE-5D-2018-0001 | | Yes | | | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Aspect ^ Sector ^ Finding summary ^ CLRTAP 2010 ^ CLRTAP 2014 ^ NECD 2017 ^ NECD 2018 ^ NECD 2019 ^ Implemented ^ Official Comment for IIR | | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Accuracy | 1A1a | Include the revised estimate of activity data and emissions for biogas in its next submission. | | | DE-1A1a-2017-0003 | DE-1A1a-2018-0001 | DE-1A1a-2017-0003 (ID reused) | No | The National Energy Balance would have to be revised | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | 2D3a | Rationale for not estimating emissions in category 2D3a and notation key selection | | | | DE-2D3a-2018-0001 | DE-2D3a-2018-0001 (ID reused) | No | Germany is in the process of evaluating data to calculate emissions of Hg from the use of fluorescent tubes. | | + | ^ Accuracy |
</ | </ | ||
- | === NECD 2017 === | + | ==== NECD 2017 ==== |
< | < | ||
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Comparability | + | ^ Comparability |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
</ | </ | ||
- | === CLRTAP 2010 & 2014 === | + | ==== CLRTAP 2010 & 2014 ==== |
< | < | ||
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ General | + | ^ General |
- | ^ General | + | ^ General |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Transparency | + | ^ Transparency |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Consistency | + | ^ Consistency |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Comparability | + | ^ Comparability |
- | ^ Comparability | + | ^ Comparability |
- | ^ Comparability | + | ^ Comparability |
- | ^ Comparability | + | ^ Comparability |
- | ^ Comparability | + | ^ Comparability |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Completeness | + | ^ Completeness |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Accuracy | + | ^ Accuracy |
- | ^ Aspect | + | ^ Aspect |
- | ^ QA/QC | | Fully implement the QA/QC system for the air pollutant emission inventory. If possible, implement a unified QA/QC system for reporting to CLRTAP and UNFCCC. | + | ^ QA/QC | |
- | ^ QA/QC | | Widen the use of the existing QA/QC system, used for the set of activity data as well as the methods and emission factors for GHGs, for the needs of CLRTAP/NECD inventories and providing further details on its implementation in the IIR (general and sectoral descriptions). | + | ^ QA/QC | |
- | ^ QA/QC | | Include information on verification and validation of the inventory in the IIR. | | § 38 | | | | No | Ongoing discussion | + | ^ QA/QC | |
</ | </ |