meta data for this page
  •  

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
sector:ippu:other_product_use:fireworks:start [2021/04/16 07:43] – [Table] kotzullasector:ippu:other_product_use:fireworks:start [2022/10/17 13:33] (current) – Fix link tarakji
Line 11: Line 11:
 ===== Methodology ===== ===== Methodology =====
  
-In the year 2019 measurements were made by a finish laboratory for the VPI – Verband der pyrotechnischen Industrie (Association of the pyrotechnical industry) of dust emissions during the burning of fire works. The experiments were made in a container in which the whole fireworks were burned.  +In 2019, measurements were made by a Finnish laboratory for the VPI – Verband der pyrotechnischen Industrie (Association of the pyrotechnical industry) of dust emissions during the burning of fire works. The experiments were made in a container in which the whole fireworks were burned. \\ 
-In 2020 the VPI and the UBA had an intensive information exchange, in which the VPI presented the results of the measurements to the UBA. The different emission factors were discussed and finally based on the expert judgement it was decided which EFs shall be used for the reporting. In the next step the activity data were updated more differentiated. Further a discussion of the other EFs was made, which led to some changes in the EFs. The results are presented below. In February 2021 the VPI has published an article in the paper "Propellants, Explosives,  Pyrotechnics" a description of the experiment together with the measurement results[(https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/prep.202000292)]. + 
 +In 2020, VPI and UBA had an intensive information exchange, in which the VPI presented the results of the measurements to the UBA. The different emission factors were discussed and finally based on the expert judgement it was decided which EFs shall be used for the reporting. In the next step the activity data were updated more differentiated.  
 + 
 +Furthermore, the other EFs have been discussed resultung in some changes to these values.  
 + 
 +The results are presented below. In February 2021 the VPI has published an article in the paper "Propellants, Explosives,  Pyrotechnics" a description of the experiment together with the measurement results[(https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/prep.202000292)]. 
  
 ==== Activity data ==== ==== Activity data ====
Line 19: Line 24:
  
 <WRAP center round box 60%> <WRAP center round box 60%>
-AR = production + import – export – disposal + return of the year before – return of the year+AD = production + import – export – disposal + return<sub>previous year</sub> – return<sub>recent year</sub>
 </WRAP> </WRAP>
  
Line 25: Line 30:
 The **production, disposal, return from the year before and return of the year** data are yearly updated by the VPI.  The **production, disposal, return from the year before and return of the year** data are yearly updated by the VPI. 
  
-**Import and export:** For the import and export data statistical data from the statistical federal office of Germany were taken (foreign statistics of federal office of statistics)[(Statistisches Bundesamt (51000-0013): Aus- und Einfuhr (Außenhandel), URL: https://www-genesis.destatis.de/genesis/online/data;sid=D7FC9DA10C87E483A48EA26969FF80CF.GO_1_5?operation=abruftabelleAbrufen&selectionname=51000-0013&levelindex=0&levelid=1552378849838&index=13)]. +**Import and export:** For the import and export data statistical data from the statistical federal office of Germany were taken (foreign statistics of federal office of statistics)[(Statistisches Bundesamt (51000-0013): Aus- und Einfuhr (Außenhandel), URL: https://www-genesis.destatis.de/genesis//online?operation=table&code=51000-0013&bypass=true&levelindex=1&levelid=1664263187988)]. 
  
 The sold amounts of fireworks have increased strongly from 1990 to 1995. From 1995 to 1997 the emissions were relatively high but decreased from 1997 to 2005. Since then, the emissions have been relatively constant with small fluctuations. The sold amounts of fireworks have increased strongly from 1990 to 1995. From 1995 to 1997 the emissions were relatively high but decreased from 1997 to 2005. Since then, the emissions have been relatively constant with small fluctuations.
 +
 +**Return**: Amount of unsold fireworks returned to producer
 +
 +**Disposal**: Amount of disposed unsold fireworks damaged during transport from producer to seller
 +
  
 ==== Emission factors ==== ==== Emission factors ====
Line 45: Line 55:
  
 __Table 2: Country-specific PM emission factors applied, in g/t product__ __Table 2: Country-specific PM emission factors applied, in g/t product__
-|             ^  PM<sub>10</sub>                          ^^  PM<sub>2.5</sub>                          ^^  TSP                                   ^^ +|             ^  PM<sub>10</sub>                  |^  PM<sub>2.5</sub>                  |^  TSP                            || 
-|             ^  Sylvester-EF     ^  During the period-EF  ^  Sylvester-EF      ^  During the period-EF  ^  Sylvester-EF  ^  During the period-EF  ^ +|             ^  New Years Eve    ^  Rest of Year  ^  New Years Eve     ^  Rest of Year  ^  New Years Eve  ^  Rest of Year  ^ 
-^  1990-2004  |  52.002,56        |  62.799,96             |  41.463,05         |  49.644,24             |  52.002,56     |  62.799,96             | +^  1990-2004  |  52.002,56        |  62.799,96     |  41.463,05         |  49.644,24     |  52.002,56      |  62.799,96     | 
-^  2005       |  47.509,31        |  72.317,11             |  38.129,60         |  57.167,68             |  47.509,31     |  72.317,11             | +^  2005       |  47.509,31        |  72.317,11     |  38.129,60         |  57.167,68     |  47.509,31      |  72.317,11     | 
-^  2006       |  45.793,40        |  71.986,67             |  36.930,61         |  56.906,46             |  45.793,40     |  71.986,67             | +^  2006       |  45.793,40        |  71.986,67     |  36.930,61         |  56.906,46     |  45.793,40      |  71.986,67     | 
-^  2007       |  45.174,65        |  72.071,88             |  36.615,74         |  56.973,82             |  45.174,65     |  72.071,88             | +^  2007       |  45.174,65        |  72.071,88     |  36.615,74         |  56.973,82     |  45.174,65      |  72.071,88     | 
-^  2008       |  45.955,36        |  71.471,31             |  37.390,41         |  56.499,06             |  45.955,36     |  71.471,31             | +^  2008       |  45.955,36        |  71.471,31     |  37.390,41         |  56.499,06     |  45.955,36      |  71.471,31     | 
-^  2009       |  45.701,68        |  70.204,58             |  37.132,12         |  55.497,69             |  45.701,68     |  70.204,58             | +^  2009       |  45.701,68        |  70.204,58     |  37.132,12         |  55.497,69     |  45.701,68      |  70.204,58     | 
-^  2010       |  44.826,79        |  69.253,15             |  36.536,80         |  54.745,57             |  44.826,79     |  69.253,15             | +^  2010       |  44.826,79        |  69.253,15     |  36.536,80         |  54.745,57     |  44.826,79      |  69.253,15     | 
-^  2011       |  44.068,30        |  68.877,53             |  36.121,87         |  54.448,64             |  44.068,30     |  68.877,53             | +^  2011       |  44.068,30        |  68.877,53     |  36.121,87         |  54.448,64     |  44.068,30      |  68.877,53     | 
-^  2012       |  45.566,16        |  69.993,91             |  37.527,36         |  55.331,16             |  45.566,16     |  69.993,91             | +^  2012       |  45.566,16        |  69.993,91     |  37.527,36         |  55.331,16     |  45.566,16      |  69.993,91     | 
-^  2013       |  46.098,42        |  67.212,39             |  38.026,91         |  53.132,33             |  46.098,42     |  67.212,39             | +^  2013       |  46.098,42        |  67.212,39     |  38.026,91         |  53.132,33     |  46.098,42      |  67.212,39     | 
-^  2014       |  46.621,17        |  67.680,72             |  38.595,22         |  53.502,55             |  46.621,17     |  67.680,72             | +^  2014       |  46.621,17        |  67.680,72     |  38.595,22         |  53.502,55     |  46.621,17      |  67.680,72     | 
-^  2015       |  47.474,24        |  67.313,58             |  39.383,93         |  53.212,31             |  47.474,24     |  67.313,58             | +^  2015       |  47.474,24        |  67.313,58     |  39.383,93         |  53.212,31     |  47.474,24      |  67.313,58     | 
-^  2016       |  47.523,35        |  66.094,38             |  39.539,55         |  52.248,52             |  47.523,35     |  66.094,38             | +^  2016       |  47.523,35        |  66.094,38     |  39.539,55         |  52.248,52     |  47.523,35      |  66.094,38     | 
-^  2017       |  47.853,44        |  65.938,58             |  39.907,83         |  52.125,36             |  47.853,44     |  65.938,58             | +^  2017       |  47.853,44        |  65.938,58     |  39.907,83         |  52.125,36     |  47.853,44      |  65.938,58     | 
-^  2018       |  48.270,00        |  63.519,57             |  39.713,09         |  50.213,10             |  48.270,00     |  63.519,57             | +^  2018       |  48.270,00        |  63.519,57     |  39.713,09         |  50.213,10     |  48.270,00      |  63.519,57     | 
-^  2019       |  48.085,00        |  63.217,87             |  40.033,58         |  49.974,60             |  48.085,00     |  63.217,87             |+^  2019       |  48.085,00        |  63.217,87     |  40.033,58         |  49.974,60     |  48.085,00      |  63.217,87     |
  
  
 The EMEP Guidebook offers Default-EFs for the pollutants Ar, Hg, Ni and Cr. But the VPI has proofed that these emissions does not occur in Germany. And the VPI has further proofed that Pb emissions does not anymore occur since 2003. See the following explanations: The EMEP Guidebook offers Default-EFs for the pollutants Ar, Hg, Ni and Cr. But the VPI has proofed that these emissions does not occur in Germany. And the VPI has further proofed that Pb emissions does not anymore occur since 2003. See the following explanations:
  
-**As and Hg:** For As and Hg the members of the VPI have confirmed that Ar and Hg are not anymore used since 1980. Since 2003 the DIN EN  14035:2003 went in force, which did forbit these substances. The actual follow up norm DIN EN 15947-5 was published in February 2016 and describes the german implementation of the harmonized and in the official journal of the European union 2017, C 149/2 published norm EN 15947:2015.+**As and Hg:** For As and Hg the members of the VPI have confirmed that Ar and Hg are not anymore used since 1980. Since About 1980 the explosives administrative regulation (Sprengverwaltungsvorschrift) is regulating which substances are allowed to be used and As and Hg are forbidden to be used. Since 2003 the DIN EN  14035:2003 went in force, which did forbit these substances. The actual follow up norm DIN EN 15947-5 was published in February 2016 and describes the german implementation of the harmonized and in the official journal of the European union 2017, C 149/2 published norm EN 15947:2015.
  
 **Pb:** As the DIN EN 14035:2003 entered into force as from 2003, which did forbid this substance, there are no Pb-emissions from fireworks from 2003 onwards. The actual follow up norm DIN EN 15947-5 was published in February 2016 and describes the german implementation of the harmonized and in the official journal of the European union 2017, C 149/2 published norm EN 15947:2015. **Pb:** As the DIN EN 14035:2003 entered into force as from 2003, which did forbid this substance, there are no Pb-emissions from fireworks from 2003 onwards. The actual follow up norm DIN EN 15947-5 was published in February 2016 and describes the german implementation of the harmonized and in the official journal of the European union 2017, C 149/2 published norm EN 15947:2015.
Line 82: Line 92:
  
 __Table 3: Change of AD between Submission 2020 and Submission 2021, in t__ __Table 3: Change of AD between Submission 2020 and Submission 2021, in t__
-^                                          ||^  1990   ^  1991   ^  1992   ^  1993   ^  1994   ^  1995   ^  1996   ^  1997   ^  1998   ^  1999   ^  2000    ^  2001   ^  2002   ^  2003   ^  2004   ^  2005   ^  2006   ^  2007   ^  2008   ^  2009   ^  2010   ^  2011   ^  2012   ^  2013   ^  2014   ^  2015   ^  2016   ^  2017   ^  2018   ^ +^                  |                  ^  1990   ^  1995   ^  2000    ^  2005   ^  2006   ^  2007   ^  2008   ^  2009   ^  2010   ^  2011   ^  2012   ^  2013   ^  2014   ^  2015   ^  2016   ^  2017   ^  2018   ^ 
-^ Submission 2021        || Sylvester        |  13,939 |  16,396 |  24,556 |  26,172 |  27,153 |  51,421 |  54,413 |  48,281 |  24,180 |  24,693 |   26,283 |  21,561 |  25,994 |  25,759 |  29,286 |  28,856 |  30,491 |  33,396 |  34,461 |  30,075 |  31,440 |  29,795 |  33,086 |  29,131 |  33,241 |  34,999 |  32,572 |  33,936 |  32,980 | +^ Submission 2021  | New Years Eve    |  13,939 |  51,421 |   26,283 |  28,856 |  30,491 |  33,396 |  34,461 |  30,075 |  31,440 |  29,795 |  33,086 |  29,131 |  33,241 |  34,999 |  32,572 |  33,936 |  32,980 | 
-| :::                    | :::  | during the year  |   4,130 |   3,493 |   5,903 |   6,138 |   6,799 |   7,447 |   7,880 |   6,993 |   5,220 |  11,483 |   10,906 |   4,741 |   6,085 |   6,256 |   8,545 |   7,506 |  10,755 |   8,235 |   8,088 |   7,521 |   8,007 |   7,499 |   8,137 |   7,247 |   8,465 |   8,832 |   9,487 |   8,544 |   9,088 | +| :::              | during the year  |   4,130 |   7,447 |   10,906 |   7,506 |  10,755 |   8,235 |   8,088 |   7,521 |   8,007 |   7,499 |   8,137 |   7,247 |   8,465 |   8,832 |   9,487 |   8,544 |   9,088 | 
-| :::                    | :::  ^ SUM              ^  18,069 ^ 19,889  ^ 30,458  ^ 32,310  ^ 33,951  ^ 58,869  ^ 62,293  ^ 55,274  ^ 29,400  ^ 36,175  ^ 37,188   ^ 26,303  ^ 32,079  ^ 32,016  ^ 37,832  ^ 36,362  ^ 41,247  ^ 41,631  ^ 42,550  ^ 37,595  ^ 39,446  ^ 37,294  ^ 41,223  ^ 36,378  ^ 41,706  ^ 43,830  ^ 42,059  ^ 42,480  ^ 42,068  ^ +| :::              ^ SUM              ^  18,069 ^ 58,869  ^ 37,188   ^ 36,362  ^ 41,247  ^ 41,631  ^ 42,550  ^ 37,595  ^ 39,446  ^ 37,294  ^ 41,223  ^ 36,378  ^ 41,706  ^ 43,830  ^ 42,059  ^ 42,480  ^ 42,068  ^ 
-^ Submission 2020                          ||^  17,957 ^  21,741 ^  37,116 ^  34,781 ^  39,579 ^  66,272 ^  69,010 ^  59,560 ^  25,605 ^  43,244 ^   48,355 ^  24,150 ^  36,462 ^  36,352 ^  46,347 ^  38,148 ^  43,487 ^  44,705 ^  42,228 ^  41,839 ^  42,652 ^  38,638 ^  42,857 ^  37,847 ^  45,164 ^  45,656 ^  45,208 ^  44,111 ^  46,462 ^ +^ Submission 2020  ^ SUM              ^  17,957 ^  66,272 ^   48,355 ^  38,148 ^  43,487 ^  44,705 ^  42,228 ^  41,839 ^  42,652 ^  38,638 ^  42,857 ^  37,847 ^  45,164 ^  45,656 ^  45,208 ^  44,111 ^  46,462 ^ 
-| Change                                   |||     112 |  -1,852 |  -6,658 |  -2,471 |  -5,628 |  -7,403 |  -6,717 |  -4,286 |   3,795 |  -7,069 |  -11,167 |   2,153 |  -4,383 |  -4,336 |  -8,516 |  -1,786 |  -2,240 |  -3,073 |     322 |  -4,244 |  -3,206 |  -1,344 |  -1,634 |  -1,469 |  -3,458 |  -1,826 |  -3,149 |  -1,631 |  -4,394 |+^ Change                             ^|     112 |  -7,403 |  -11,167 |  -1,786 |  -2,240 |  -3,073 |     322 |  -4,244 |  -3,206 |  -1,344 |  -1,634 |  -1,469 |  -3,458 |  -1,826 |  -3,149 |  -1,631 |  -4,394 |
  
 {{ :sector:ippu:other_product_use:fireworks:fireworks_emissions.png |}} {{ :sector:ippu:other_product_use:fireworks:fireworks_emissions.png |}}
Line 96: Line 106:
      
 __Table 4: Change of emissions between Submission 2020 and Submission 2021, in t__ __Table 4: Change of emissions between Submission 2020 and Submission 2021, in t__
-^             ^  Pollutant  ^ Source            ^  1990     ^  1995      ^  2000      ^  2005      ^  2010      ^  2015      ^  2016      ^  2017      ^  2018      ^ +^                  ^  Pollutant  ^ Source            ^  1990    ^  1995    ^  2000    ^  2005    ^  2010    ^  2015    ^  2016    ^  2017    ^  2018    ^ 
-^ Subm2020    ^  As         ^                   |     0,024 |      0,088 |      0,064 |      0,051 |      0,057 |      0,061 |      0,060 |      0,059 |      0,062 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  As         ^                   |    0,024 |    0,088 |    0,064 |    0,051 |    0,057 |    0,061 |    0,060 |    0,059 |    0,062 | 
-^ Subm2021    | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |  NA                                                                                      ||||||||| 
-^ Subm2021    | :::         ^ rest of the year  |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  | :::                                                                                      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | 
-^ Difference  | :::         ^                   |    -0,024 |     -0,088 |     -0,064 |     -0,051 |     -0,057 |     -0,061 |     -0,060 |     -0,059 |     -0,062 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |   -0,024 |   -0,088 |   -0,064 |   -0,051 |   -0,057 |   -0,061 |   -0,060 |   -0,059 |   -0,062 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  Cd         ^                   |     0,027 |      0,098 |      0,072 |      0,057 |      0,063 |      0,068 |      0,067 |      0,065 |      0,069 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  Cd         ^                   |    0,027 |    0,098 |    0,072 |    0,057 |    0,063 |    0,068 |    0,067 |    0,065 |    0,069 | 
-^ Subm2021    | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |  NA                                                                                      ||||||||| 
-^ Subm2021    | :::         ^ rest of the year  |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  | :::                                                                                      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | 
-^ Difference  | :::         ^                   |    -0,027 |     -0,098 |     -0,072 |     -0,056 |     -0,063 |     -0,068 |     -0,067 |     -0,065 |     -0,069 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |   -0,027 |   -0,098 |   -0,072 |   -0,056 |   -0,063 |   -0,068 |   -0,067 |   -0,065 |   -0,069 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  CO         ^                   |   128,392 |    473,843 |    345,740 |    272,759 |    304,960 |    326,443 |    323,239 |    315,392 |    332,201 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  CO         ^                   |  128,392 |  473,843 |  345,740 |  272,759 |  304,960 |  326,443 |  323,239 |  315,392 |  332,201 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  CO         ^ New Years Eve     |    99,664 |    367,662 |    187,921 |    206,322 |    224,792 |    250,241 |    232,888 |    242,640 |    235,805 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |   99,664 |  367,662 |  187,921 |  206,322 |  224,792 |  250,241 |  232,888 |  242,640 |  235,805 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  CO         ^ rest of the year  |    29,530 |     53,247 |     77,976 |     53,664 |     57,247 |     63,145 |     67,833 |     61,090 |     64,979 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |   29,530 |   53,247 |   77,976 |   53,664 |   57,247 |   63,145 |   67,833 |   61,090 |   64,979 | 
-^ Difference  ^  CO         ^                   |     0,802 |    -52,934 |    -79,843 |    -12,773 |    -22,920 |    -13,057 |    -22,518 |    -11,662 |    -31,417 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |    0,802 |  -52,934 |  -79,843 |  -12,773 |  -22,920 |  -13,057 |  -22,518 |  -11,662 |  -31,417 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  Cr         ^                   |     0,280 |      1,034 |      0,754 |      0,595 |      0,665 |      0,712 |      0,705 |      0,688 |      0,725 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  Cr         ^                   |    0,280 |    1,034 |    0,754 |    0,595 |    0,665 |    0,712 |    0,705 |    0,688 |    0,725 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Cr         ^ New Years Eve     |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |  NA                                                                                      ||||||||| 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Cr         ^ rest of the year  |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  | :::                                                                                      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | 
-^ Difference  ^  Cr         ^                   |    -0,280 |     -1,034 |     -0,754 |     -0,595 |     -0,665 |     -0,712 |     -0,705 |     -0,688 |     -0,725 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |   -0,280 |   -1,034 |   -0,754 |   -0,595 |   -0,665 |   -0,712 |   -0,705 |   -0,688 |   -0,725 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  Cu         ^                   |     7,973 |     29,425 |     21,470 |     16,938 |     18,937 |     20,271 |     20,072 |     19,585 |     20,629 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  Cu         ^                   |    7,973 |   29,425 |   21,470 |   16,938 |   18,937 |   20,271 |   20,072 |   19,585 |   20,629 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Cu         ^ New Years Eve     |     6,189 |     22,831 |     11,670 |     12,812 |     13,959 |     15,539 |     14,462 |     15,067 |     14,643 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |    6,189 |   22,831 |   11,670 |   12,812 |   13,959 |   15,539 |   14,462 |   15,067 |   14,643 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Cu         ^ rest of the year  |     1,834 |      3,307 |      4,842 |      3,332 |      3,555 |      3,921 |      4,212 |      3,794 |      4,035 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |    1,834 |    3,307 |    4,842 |    3,332 |    3,555 |    3,921 |    4,212 |    3,794 |    4,035 | 
-^ Difference  ^  Cu         ^                   |     0,050 |     -3,287 |     -4,958 |     -0,793 |     -1,423 |     -0,811 |     -1,398 |     -0,724 |     -1,951 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |    0,050 |   -3,287 |   -4,958 |   -0,793 |   -1,423 |   -0,811 |   -1,398 |   -0,724 |   -1,951 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  Hg         ^                   |     0,001 |      0,004 |      0,003 |      0,002 |      0,002 |      0,003 |      0,003 |      0,003 |      0,003 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  Hg         ^                   |    0,001 |    0,004 |    0,003 |    0,002 |    0,002 |    0,003 |    0,003 |    0,003 |    0,003 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Hg         ^ New Years Eve     |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |  NA                                                                                      ||||||||| 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Hg         ^ rest of the year  |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  | :::                                                                                      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | 
-^ Difference  ^  Hg         ^                   |    -0,001 |     -0,004 |     -0,003 |     -0,002 |     -0,002 |     -0,003 |     -0,003 |     -0,003 |     -0,003 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |   -0,001 |   -0,004 |   -0,003 |   -0,002 |   -0,002 |   -0,003 |   -0,003 |   -0,003 |   -0,003 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  Ni         ^                   |     0,539 |      1,988 |      1,451 |      1,144 |      1,280 |      1,370 |      1,356 |      1,323 |      1,394 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  Ni         ^                   |    0,539 |    1,988 |    1,451 |    1,144 |    1,280 |    1,370 |    1,356 |    1,323 |    1,394 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Ni         ^ New Years Eve     |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |  NA                                                                                      ||||||||| 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Ni         ^ rest of the year  |     0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  | :::                                                                                      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | :::      | 
-^ Difference  ^  Ni         ^                   |    -0,539 |     -1,988 |     -1,451 |     -1,144 |     -1,280 |     -1,370 |     -1,356 |     -1,323 |     -1,394 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |   -0,539 |   -1,988 |   -1,451 |   -1,144 |   -1,280 |   -1,370 |   -1,356 |   -1,323 |   -1,394 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  NOx        ^                   |     4,669 |     17,231 |     12,572 |      9,919 |     11,089 |     11,871 |     11,754 |     11,469 |     12,080 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  NOx        ^                   |    4,669 |   17,231 |   12,572 |    9,919 |   11,089 |   11,871 |   11,754 |   11,469 |   12,080 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  NOx        ^ New Years Eve     |     3,624 |     13,370 |      6,834 |      7,503 |      8,174 |      9,100 |      8,469 |      8,823 |      8,575 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |    3,624 |   13,370 |    6,834 |    7,503 |    8,174 |    9,100 |    8,469 |    8,823 |    8,575 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  NOx        ^ rest of the year  |     1,074 |      1,936 |      2,835 |      1,951 |      2,082 |      2,296 |      2,467 |      2,221 |      2,363 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |    1,074 |    1,936 |    2,835 |    1,951 |    2,082 |    2,296 |    2,467 |    2,221 |    2,363 | 
-^ Difference  ^  NOx        ^                   |     0,029 |     -1,925 |     -2,903 |     -0,464 |     -0,833 |     -0,475 |     -0,819 |     -0,424 |     -1,142 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |    0,029 |   -1,925 |   -2,903 |   -0,464 |   -0,833 |   -0,475 |   -0,819 |   -0,424 |   -1,142 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  Pb         ^                   |    14,078 |     51,957 |     37,911 |     29,908 |     33,439 |     35,795 |     35,443 |     34,583 |     36,426 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  Pb         ^                   |   14,078 |   51,957 |   37,911 |   29,908 |   33,439 |   35,795 |   35,443 |   34,583 |   36,426 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Pb         ^ New Years Eve     |    10,928 |     24,809 |      4,755 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |   10,928 |   24,809 |    4,755 |    0,000 |    0,000 |    0,000 |    0,000 |    0,000 |    0,000 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Pb         ^ rest of the year  |     3,238 |      3,593 |      1,973 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 |      0,000 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |    3,238 |    3,593 |    1,973 |    0,000 |    0,000 |    0,000 |    0,000 |    0,000 |    0,000 | 
-^ Difference  ^  Pb         ^                   |     0,088 |    -23,555 |    -31,182 |    -29,908 |    -33,439 |    -35,795 |    -35,443 |    -34,583 |    -36,426 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |    0,088 |  -23,555 |  -31,182 |  -29,908 |  -33,439 |  -35,795 |  -35,443 |  -34,583 |  -36,426 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  PM 10      ^                   |           |   6621,880 |   4831,660 |   3811,760 |   4261,760 |   4561,980 |   4517,210 |   4407,540 |   4642,450 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  PM10       ^                   |          |     6622 |     4832 |     3812 |     4262 |     4562 |     4517 |     4408 |     4642 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  PM 10      ^ New Years Eve     |           |   2674,040 |   1366,770 |   1370,940 |   1409,330 |   1661,540 |   1547,920 |   1623,940 |   1591,930 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |          |     2674 |     1367 |     1371 |     1409 |     1662 |     1548 |     1624 |     1592 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  PM 10      ^ rest of the year  |           |    467,684 |    684,878 |    542,776 |    554,482 |    594,480 |    627,051 |    563,379 |    577,266 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |          |      468 |      685 |      543 |      554 |      594 |      627 |      563 |      577 | 
-^ Difference  ^  PM 10      ^                   |           |  -3480,155 |  -2780,016 |  -1898,047 |  -2297,944 |  -2305,961 |  -2342,246 |  -2220,222 |  -2473,257 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |          |    -3480 |    -2780 |    -1898 |    -2298 |    -2306 |    -2342 |    -2220 |    -2473 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  PM 2.5     ^                   |           |   3442,160 |   2511,570 |   1981,410 |   2215,330 |   2371,390 |   2348,120 |   2291,110 |   2413,220 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  PM2.5      ^                   |          |     3442 |     2512 |     1981 |     2215 |     2371 |     2348 |     2291 |     2413 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  PM 2.5     ^ New Years Eve     |           |   2132,080 |   1089,760 |   1100,280 |   1148,700 |   1378,390 |   1287,870 |   1354,300 |   1309,730 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |          |     2132 |     1090 |     1100 |     1149 |     1378 |     1288 |     1354 |     1310 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  PM 2.5     ^ rest of the year  |           |    369,711 |    541,405 |    429,072 |    438,326 |    469,945 |    495,692 |    445,359 |    456,337 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |          |      370 |      541 |      429 |      438 |      470 |      496 |      445 |      456 | 
-^ Difference  ^  PM 2.5     ^                   |           |   -940,363 |   -880,408 |   -452,067 |   -628,305 |   -523,057 |   -564,557 |   -491,450 |   -647,158 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |          |     -940 |     -880 |     -452 |     -628 |     -523 |     -565 |     -491 |     -647 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  SO2        ^                   |    54,230 |    200,141 |    146,033 |    115,207 |    128,808 |    137,882 |    136,529 |    133,214 |    140,314 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  SO2        ^                   |   54,230 |  200,141 |  146,033 |  115,207 |  128,808 |  137,882 |  136,529 |  133,214 |  140,314 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  SO2        ^ New Years Eve     |    42,096 |    155,292 |     79,374 |     87,146 |     94,947 |    105,696 |     98,367 |    102,486 |     99,599 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |   42,096 |  155,292 |   79,374 |   87,146 |   94,947 |  105,696 |   98,367 |  102,486 |   99,599 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  SO2        ^ rest of the year  |    12,473 |     22,491 |     32,935 |     22,667 |     24,180 |     26,671 |     28,651 |     25,803 |     27,446 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |   12,473 |   22,491 |   32,935 |   22,667 |   24,180 |   26,671 |   28,651 |   25,803 |   27,446 | 
-^ Difference  ^  SO2        ^                   |     0,339 |    -22,358 |    -33,724 |     -5,395 |     -9,681 |     -5,515 |     -9,511 |     -4,926 |    -13,270 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |    0,339 |  -22,358 |  -33,724 |   -5,395 |   -9,681 |   -5,515 |   -9,511 |   -4,926 |  -13,270 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  TSP        ^                   |  1972,210 |   7278,630 |   5310,860 |   4189,810 |   4684,440 |   5014,430 |   4965,230 |   4844,680 |   5102,890 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  TSP        ^                   |     1972 |     7279 |     5311 |     4190 |     4684 |     5014 |     4965 |     4845 |     5103 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  TSP        ^ New Years Eve     |   724,864 |   2674,040 |   1366,770 |   1370,940 |   1409,330 |   1661,540 |   1547,920 |   1623,940 |   1591,930 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |      725 |     2674 |     1367 |     1371 |     1409 |     1662 |     1548 |     1624 |     1592 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  TSP        ^ rest of the year  |   259,370 |    467,684 |    684,878 |    542,776 |    554,482 |    594,480 |    627,051 |    563,379 |    577,266 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |      259 |      468 |      685 |      543 |      554 |      594 |      627 |      563 |      577 | 
-^ Difference  ^  TSP        ^                   |  -987,973 |  -4136,909 |  -3259,218 |  -2276,095 |  -2720,622 |  -2758,415 |  -2790,261 |  -2657,359 |  -2933,693 | +^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |     -988 |    -4137 |    -3259 |    -2276 |    -2721 |    -2758 |    -2790 |    -2657 |    -2934 | 
-^ Subm2020    ^  Zn         ^                   |     4,669 |     17,231 |     12,572 |      9,919 |     11,089 |     11,871 |     11,754 |     11,469 |     12,080 | +^ Submission 2020  ^  Zn         ^                   |    4,669 |   17,231 |   12,572 |    9,919 |   11,089 |   11,871 |   11,754 |   11,469 |   12,080 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Zn         ^ New Years Eve     |     3,624 |     13,370 |      6,834 |      7,503 |      8,174 |      9,100 |      8,469 |      8,823 |      8,575 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ New Years Eve     |    3,624 |   13,370 |    6,834 |    7,503 |    8,174 |    9,100 |    8,469 |    8,823 |    8,575 | 
-^ Subm2021    ^  Zn         ^ rest of the year  |     1,074 |      1,936 |      2,835 |      1,951 |      2,082 |      2,296 |      2,467 |      2,221 |      2,363 | +^ Submission 2021  | :::         ^ rest of the year  |    1,074 |    1,936 |    2,835 |    1,951 |    2,082 |    2,296 |    2,467 |    2,221 |    2,363 | 
-^ Difference  ^  Zn         ^                   |     0,029 |     -1,925 |     -2,903 |     -0,464 |     -0,833 |     -0,475 |     -0,819 |     -0,424 |     -1,142 |+^ Difference       | :::         ^                   |    0,029 |   -1,925 |   -2,903 |   -0,464 |   -0,833 |   -0,475 |   -0,819 |   -0,424 |   -1,142 |
  
 <WRAP center round info 60%> <WRAP center round info 60%>